Do you believe that successful trader share their secrets

Do you believe that successful trader share their secrets to others.
every successful person have their own secret to become a successful trader one day the will no share their secret because by using their secrets people will become successful like them.

mera khiyal ma successful trader bana k koi secret nai hai.es k liya meri nazar ma eak he secret hai wo hai proper knowledge or proper trading experience agar ye 2 no cheze hai ap k pass tu ap es ma kamyab ho sakhtye hai.

yes why not i have read and watch many interview of the success full trader if they are rich and have become the successful then they can share their experience and i think it is a thought of honur for them

mare dost gee bilkul me is baat per pore believe karta ho ky successfull trader appani success ky secrets dosaroo se zaro share karty hai but ye hum per hai hum un ky secrats per believe kary ya nai kary lakin wo tu appne secrets open kar hai.

no i am not agree with you, a successful trader kabi be ap ko apna secret nai da ga trader kiya koi be business man apna business secret nai data.

no i will agree with you. jo aap bat keh rahe ho yeh lazmi ni ke har successfull trader achi soch rakhta ho, kuch ache traders hote hain aur kuch bure hote hain leken mere khyal ke mutabiq hume strategies share lazmi karni chahyea take dosro ka faida ho saqe.

i disagree and also agree. i disagree because i have personally see that with a friend of mine helps me at lot of the areas where i struggles and he helps me
i agree because in professional life and in business people try to maximize their profit and minimize their losses as compare to other person they only give information which is not helpful for him. they did not provide their secrete
thanks

i do not think that they will never share their secret i think forex is a business and every successful trader will 100% share their idea in the trading in rare i think few may be willl not share the experience of the trading

bahtrin trader banny ky liye ap koapny cam ky bary main bahtrin nolag hona chahia os ky sath sath ap past our copy na kary kayo ky wo forex ke compuny ke halaf hain

This really does not happens but I think they should share their experience with each other due to which new traders will learn how to trade so i thnk there will be healthy trading then so try to share your experience with each other and do not hide.....

yes my dear i think they will share i do not think that they will not share the ideas of the successful story i think if we are think like that it is not the right may be one out of 100 not share the idea on this

Jahan tak mere pass knowledge hay forex trading ka mere khiyal too too forex main trading ka koi secret nahee hy haan forex main kamyab trader bany ky ly app ky pass joo secret hona chahiye wo forex ka knowledge aur experience hy.

yes mere khaayal main sab kamyab traders ban sakty hain bas humein knowledge ka hasi karna chahyeh aur market trend ko samjnaa chahyeh baki ap kamyab ho sakty hoo aur apney secrets share kar sakty ho easily

thak kha koi bhi apna raz nhi batya ga aur hamsha dobta who he hy jo tarta hy aur jitna hum ko malom ho ga trading ka utna he fida ho ga hum ko aur hum ko koi bhi apna scret kyo baty ga koi nhi chy ga ky koi acha trader ban jy

mene forex ko 3 mnth pahly join kia aur mai tab sy ab tak forex k sath hun trading kar raha hun aur muje demo par b kfi arsa ho gaya hai kam karty huye,shayad e ko batataho apny secrets trading,