successful traders should share their success secret or not

Brother jaha tak mera khayal hai sab logo ki apni apni nature hoti hai is tarah tamam tar successful trader apna secret share nai kerte hai , kuch log apni mehnat ki waja se jo gain kiya hota hai , us se kisi or koi gain nai kerne dete hai ,or jo ache log hote hai wo sab k saat apna secret share kerte wo chahte hai k dosre log b kamyab ho jaye .

it's depend on trader mind but i think that as a good trader every successful and experienced trader need share his experience to other trader specially in new trader...

Well, dear mry khyal ma apni successful ki story ko share krny ma koi qabahat nhe huni chahy. Hu sakta hy k us sy aap ko he koi faida hujay. or ye bhe mumkin hy k aap ki story ko dekh kr koi or apni mistakes ko control krly.

successful traders ko apni secrects share karni chahien or wo share karty bhi hain but hamain bhi experts ki respect karni chahiey or un kay threads ko read karna chahiey.is tarah kaafi help mil jaati hai.

to my way of thinking, successful traders should share their secrets but not to everyone. A successful trader should share secrets with people who can understand those secrets and can work accordingly, otherwise it will not be wise from any angle to share your secrets with everyone.

I do agree with you that a successful trader should disclose their trading success with those couleagues who are familiar with trading other wise it may harm to forex and trader so a trader should always be cautious about disclosing his or her strategies to other persons.:)

g han bilkul successful traders ko apna experience share krna chahiye kyon ke un ke experience se or buht se logon ko faeda ho ga buht se loag earn krna start kr skte hain unhain newcomers ko sikhana chahiye

je han app ko es main boht ache chance lugte hain app es main kafi earnign kar skt eho aur kmayab be hote ho so app o dekhna hoga aur appp ko kmaayab hona hoga so es amin app ko capital zayda karna hota hai

yes i think hamen is forum par bohot sarey aisey senior trader bhi miltey hain jo yahan par apni strategy dusre logon se share kar rahey hotey hain takeh baqi bhi sab log is sey achi trha sey faida utha saken.

forex trading me bohat sy aisy traders he jo k apna knowledge dosron k sath share karty he is knowledge sy new forex traders ko b bohat zyada fayda hota he or wo loss sy bach sakty hen ...

dear mere khiyal say bohat say log hoty hain jo yeh chahty hain kay wo apna success hony ka secret kisi ko na btae wo yeh chahty hain kay sirf wohi success hasil kar saky koi or success hasil na kar saky is liye wo apna secret kisi ko nahi btatay.

Apne secrets share to karne chahian laikan aj k es selfish dour mein aisa kam hota hai kiunke aisa karne waly samjty hain k shayed un ka profit kam ho jay ga laikan ye un ki bhool hai kisi ka faida kare wale ka ALLAH faida zaror karty hain.

I think no any secret in this business for success becasue forex is very open book fro peoples.. and if you will learn and you will spend more time on learning and you will follow trading rules so then you can get success in this business..

Jee bhai meri nazar mein yeh log koi chez sahre nai kartea ap ko chea kea beginers trader kea liea bhi ap log un kea sath apni trading kea secret shares kar aur phr ap log esily achi earning kar sketa hea.

i am not agree with this argument my dear friend ku kay asay log bohat he kam hotay haan jo apni undar ki batain dosaro ko batatain haan maray dost .wo chupatay haan batain jo un ko yaha tak lae haan

mery hisab se tu professional traders ya successful traders ko apny secrets ziada share karny chahiay kiun kay agar wo apny secrets kisi ko bata dain gay tu log us trader ki respect bhi Karen gay or us trader ko apni trading pe proud bhi hoga kay wo apny knowledge ko spread kar raha hai. Agar koi successful trader apny secret bata bhi de ga tu iss me uska koi nuqsan nahi hoga kiun kay is se log market se hi benefit lain gay.